

Nautilus News
Mar 15th, 2008
In the US, there is no nationally recognized standard or definition for the terms “natural” or “organic” when they appear on the labels of our favorite foods and personal care products. Debate is on-going but the value behind each of the words is mostly left up to the interpretation of each product’s manufacturer. One consumer watchdog group, the Organic Consumers Association (OCA), has recently uncovered small amounts of a petroleum-based ingredient, known to cause cancer in animals, in some cleaning and personal grooming products manufactured and distributed by some of the leading names in the natural and organic arena.
Small amounts of 1,4-dioxane, a solvent, was found in 46 out of 100 popular products, which ranged from shampoos to shower gels to dishwashing soaps. The solvent isn’t a deliberate addition to the products and so is not cited on the ingredients lists. It is a manufacturing by-product instead.
It is important to note that, although there are no federally required regulations sanctioning the use of the terms natural and organic, the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) does issue a seal of organic certification to products that meet its own tests and standards.
To earn the USDA organic seal, 95% or more of a product must be made from organic ingredients. Using the seal in violation of agency policy can result in penalties totalling $11,000 for each violation. Of the products tested in the OCA survey, none of the products bearing the USDA organic seal contained any trace of the solvent at all.
To illustrate the extent to which standards vary, The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) claims the amount of 1,4-dioxane usually found in cosmetics doesn’t pose a risk to consumers.
The Consumer Product Safety Commission, chartered to regulate household cleaning agents, does not identify a danger limit for the 1,4-dioxane and evaluates each case as it occurs.
The state of California requires a warning label, identifying the risk of cancer, on any products that contain an excess of 30 parts per million (ppm) of 1,4-dioxane. Levels as high as 97.1 ppm were found in one of the liquid dishwashing detergents tested.
Some of the products that tested positive for the solvent include Jason Fragrance Free Satin Soap and Alba Botanical Passion Fruit Body Wash. A spokesperson for Hain Celestial, owners of the Jason and Alba brands, says the term “pure, natural, and organic” on Jason products refers only to the products’ ingredients. Within the Alba line, no claims or “organic” are made and “natural” simply means they try to use ingredients from natural sources whenever possible.
Whole Foods Market’s 365 Everyday Value Shower Gel was also on the list of solvent-positive products. Claiming the term “natural” but not “organic” for the 365 Everday Value product line, a spokesman for Whole Foods Markets says the company has plans to investigate further.
Citrus Magic 100 Percent Natural Dish Liquid, manufactured by Beaumont Products, was found to contain trace amounts of 1,4-dioxane, too. In a statement describing the findings of the OCA test as the first the company had heard of the presence of the solvent, the company’s technical director says there are plans to review its raw materials and any other potential sources of contamination.
The OCA is a private organization that receives funding from private donations and corporate grants. Two of its founders own lines of personal care products. One of them, Dr. Bronner’s Magic Soaps, tested negative to the presence of 1,4-dioxane. The other line, Intelligent Nutrients, was not tested because it’s area of distribution is limited.
Source: Organic Consumers Association
No comments:
Post a Comment